They are saying we’re all the time imagined to be shifting ahead. Develop, enhance, evolve. While you tag a six-pointer, subsequent 12 months it should be an eight, then a ten. In the event you shot a 120-inch buck, the following one higher break 140. That’s the unwritten rule within the looking world, the one no person says out loud however everyone feels. Generally, although, the one means ahead is a step again—a stumble.
Generally the lesson doesn’t present up as a trophy, however as a scar, or a tiny set of antlers barely poking by the hair on a younger buck’s head.
Get The Drone
On November sixth, 2024, I shot a buck and didn’t recuperate him.
For some peace of thoughts, I employed a thermal drone restoration crew. Not lengthy after takeoff, they noticed a carcass. My coronary heart sank, when as a result of it wasn’t my buck. A neighborhood Fb group later confirmed it belonged to a different hunter. My deer, it appeared, wasn’t hit lethally and would dwell.
You’d suppose that may really feel like aid. It didn’t. It was worse. Like a foul dream you’ll be able to’t wake from. I spent the following few days away from the woods, licking my wounds and attempting to absorb high quality time with my household.
It nonetheless stings to say it out loud: I shot a deer and didn’t recuperate it.
It’s the type of failure that festers in a hunter’s thoughts like an itch you’ll be able to’t fairly attain. You replay each second of the shot, slow-motion, from draw to affect. You doubt your bow, your broadhead, your choices, and worst of all, your self.
I instructed myself I’d dangle it up for the season, as a result of that’d be the accountable factor to do. The reality was extra easy: I didn’t need to fail once more. My ego was bruised, and I needed to flee that feeling. Going again to the woods, may carry all of it again.
However ego doesn’t die quietly. It thrashes. It claws. And typically it drags you proper again into the woods, whether or not you’re prepared or not. Fortunately, the deer woods is a spot for deep therapeutic, too.
Ten days later, I used to be again.
The Return to the Deer Woods
On November sixteenth 2024, I used to be paddling my canoe by a stretch of southeastern Wisconsin public land that doesn’t surrender deer simply. My lungs burned from a chilly I couldn’t shake, and the air felt like I used to be respiratory by cheesecloth.
By the point I reached my spot, I noticed I’d forgotten my saddle platform, a type of particulars that separates regular hunters from an Okayest Hunter. I laughed at myself. Traditional transfer, in fact, I forgot a crucial piece of looking gear. If the day was already the wrong way up, I figured I’d as nicely lean into it.
So I hunted from the bottom.

Because the solar bled out over the canary grass, I heard rustling within the marsh. Out stepped a spike buck, shifting proper down the path I used to be sitting on, closing the gap till he was perhaps 5 yards away on the final attainable minute of authorized taking pictures gentle.
He wasn’t a wall-hanger. Not even shut. Only a residing, respiratory deer, fully unaware he was about to turn out to be a part of a a lot greater story.
I considered one thing Jarrod Scheffler as soon as mentioned on Whitetail Adrenaline:
“If the hunt will get me excited, I’ll shoot the deer, whatever the dimension of its rack.”
My coronary heart was hammering. My palms slicked up across the bow grip. This wasn’t about redemption by inches of antler; it was about proving I may nonetheless get it achieved. Proving my gear labored. Proving to myself I may fill the freezer.
The arrow discovered its mark. A clear pass-through. The lighted nock was shining vibrant by thick grass, and I adopted the blood path simply at first. Then it thinned.

I’ll admit it, my thoughts began to unravel. The considered dropping one other deer crept in like a chilly draft. However I saved looking out, scanning for each tiny fleck of pink. I slowed right down to a crawl, shifting by the darkish hardwoods like a methodical sloth investigating a criminal offense scene.
Then I caught the faint reflection of eyes at floor stage. Fifteen yards past the place the path had gone chilly, there he was. My deer.
The aid hit like a wave. Gratitude. After all of the noise in my head that season, the silence that adopted discovering that deer within the silent darkness of the hardwoods was the most effective sound on this planet.
Paddling on a Treadmill
Dragging him by the hardwoods after which the thick canary grass, sick as a canine, I began laughing once more, as a result of I don’t suppose my contaminated lungs or small canoe may have dealt with a deer any bigger than the one I tagged. Each paddle stroke upriver felt like dropping two. Someplace in that exhaustion, I discovered peace. In all probability as a result of, for the primary time all season, I wasn’t chasing one thing, I used to be simply doing the work.
I’d set a objective early that 12 months: take a deer on public land, from the water, and paddle it out. I lastly did it.

Once I received residence and pulled the little buck into the storage, my seven-year-old daughter got here out in her pajamas, excited to see what I’d introduced residence.
She squinted on the deer and requested, “Is it a buck or a doe?”
The rack was sufficiently small that I couldn’t blame her for asking. I instructed her it was just a little buck. She nodded, considerate as ever, and mentioned, “Properly, we’re nonetheless going to eat it, proper?”
That line hit more durable than the countless paddle strokes headed upstream, the fever, or the misplaced buck from ten days earlier. Her voice was the one I didn’t know I wanted to quiet my very own. The one which jogged my memory why I hunt within the first place.
Studying Exhausting Classes From My Daughter
That small deer stuffed our freezer. It stuffed our dinner plates. It stuffed a spot in my confidence that antlers by no means may.
That season, I didn’t get many sits. Three, perhaps 4. I missed chunks of November touring with my household. I by no means had a doe inside vary. However that little spike was sufficient.
Redemption doesn’t all the time put on a crown of antlers. Generally it wears buttons. Generally it humbles you, makes you sick, after which quietly reminds you of who you’re; an Okayest Hunter in my case.
So to the on a regular basis hunters grinding it out between work and household, and life, chasing daylight and hope on crowded public land, keep in mind to all the time be happy with your tag. The inches don’t matter when the meat’s within the freezer and your children are across the desk.
It’s okay to take a step again. To shoot a smaller buck. To fill the freezer as an alternative of your ego.
In any case, you’re nonetheless going to eat it, proper?

Revealed by Eric Clark — Cofounder of Okayest Hunter













