The origin and historical past of the Antiquities Act and presidential nationwide monument powers in the US.
The Antiquities Act of 1906 and the creation of nationwide monuments are intently linked. The Antiquities Act granted presidents the authority to designate nationwide monuments with out Congressional approval. It additionally established laws for archaeological investigations on federal lands. This consists of allowing, artifact elimination, and the requirement that important objects be preserved in public museums.
Nationwide monuments, when thought-about within the context of huge tracts of land, are wins for searching entry. Nonetheless, as a result of complexity of the subject and the truth that most nationwide monuments haven’t any searching significance in anyway, misunderstandings about how this public land designation impacts our searching rights are widespread. Moreover, the phrase “Antiquities” can typically trigger confusion concerning the Nationwide Monument designation course of.
On this article, we are going to discover the authorized authority behind nationwide monuments. We may also take a look at the historical past of the lands affected. Lastly, we’ll overview the presidents who’ve exercised or challenged this energy since President Theodore Roosevelt signed An Act for the Preservation of American Antiquities into regulation on June eighth, 1906.
Creating Nationwide Monuments is a Presidential Energy
As you would possibly anticipate, this story is as a lot about Theodore Roosevelt, the “Conservation President,” and his legacy as it’s about presidential authority to designate and defend public lands.
Earlier than the creation of the Antiquities Act, the one express authority a president needed to designate public lands got here from the Forest Reserves Act of 1891. This act finally led to the Nationwide Forest system as we all know it right this moment. Exterior of that regulation, nonetheless, Congress held the only authority to create and designate public lands.
Amongst many issues, Theodore Roosevelt examined presidential energy in one of the progressive and controversial methods. His designation of over 50 hen sanctuaries by govt orders was extremely unpopular, significantly inside his personal social gathering. These orders halted industrial actions on protected lands, together with market searching, land growth, and mineral and vitality extraction. Many argue—and I agree—that these hen sanctuaries, most of which later grew to become Nationwide Wildlife Refuges, performed a vital function in stopping the extinction of quite a few hen species within the twentieth century.
That matter, nonetheless, deserves a whole article of its personal.
However Roosevelt wished to do extra. Enter Congressman John Lacey, a key determine in conservation coverage and the creator of the Lacey Act of 1900. Lacey served because the lead sponsor of the Antiquities Act. It gained broad assist from the Democrats and progressive Republicans of the time. As anticipated, there was additionally important resistance, primarily from personal and capitalist pursuits. In the end, the extra conservation-focused method prevailed.
Following the Act’s passage, President Theodore Roosevelt created the primary nationwide monument, Devils Tower in Wyoming, on September 24, 1906. By the top of his presidency, he designated 18 nationwide monuments.
Necessities for Nationwide Monument Designation
Part 2 of the Antiquities Act grants the president the facility to designate nationwide monuments. It states: “The President of the US is permitted, in his discretion, to declare by public proclamation historic landmarks, historic and prehistoric constructions, and different objects of historic or scientific curiosity which might be located upon the lands owned or managed by the Authorities of the US to be nationwide monuments, and will reserve as an element thereof parcels of land, the boundaries of which in all circumstances shall be confined to the smallest space appropriate with correct care and administration of the objects to be protected.”
Three key parts of this statute are as follows:
The land should already be “owned or managed by the Authorities of the US.”
The realm should comprise “historic landmarks, historic and prehistoric constructions, or different objects of historic or scientific curiosity.”
The designated land should be “the smallest space appropriate with the right care and administration of the objects to be protected.”
For the reason that passing of the Antiquities Act, 18 of the 21 presidents since Theodore Roosevelt have exercised the presidential energy to create a nationwide monument 159 instances. The one presidents throughout that interval who didn’t create nationwide monuments are Richard Nixon, Ronald Reagan, and George H. W. Bush.
How Does Making a Nationwide Monument Impression Federal Land Protections?
So if the federal authorities already owns the land, what does making a nationwide monument really do?
Essentially the most important safety a nationwide monument supplies is shielding the land from industrial growth, together with mining and vitality. As hunters and conservationists, these designations are everlasting wins for future generations. It makes it extraordinarily tough to unload these lands or open them for mineral or vitality extraction of any sort. It’s essential to notice that even when public lands, nationwide monuments or in any other case, are federally owned, lands which might be open to extraction turn into closed to searching.
Nonetheless, you will need to make clear that nationwide monuments are sometimes not large tracts of land. As a substitute, they have a tendency to incorporate locations just like the Statue of Liberty or Indigenous cultural websites. The Nationwide Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) usually manages the biggest nationwide monuments, that are marine-based. Many of those nationwide monuments permit leisure angling, however in nearly all circumstances, they prohibit industrial fishing.
On land, the biggest nationwide monuments are sometimes positioned within the West or in Alaska. Within the East, the huge Katahdin Woods and Waters Nationwide Monument is positioned in Maine. Usually, the Bureau of Land Administration (BLM), U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and U.S. Forest Service (USFS) manages them. In addition they occur to be the businesses most related to hunters, as they often permit liberal searching and angling entry (together with skilled guiding).
Moreover, many of those nationwide monuments nonetheless permit livestock grazing, although they might impose stricter necessities and modifications to future allowing. Nonetheless, the designation sometimes grandfathers in any pre-existing livestock use by default.
Essentially the most restrictive insurance policies have a tendency to use to monuments managed by the Nationwide Park Service (NPS). This company oversees 89 of the 138 nationwide monuments. Nonetheless, most of those NPS-managed websites are small. They embody historic homes or constructions, and plenty of are on lower than an acre of land. Exceptions the place searching is allowed inside NPS-managed nationwide monuments embody these with important hunting-relevant land, comparable to areas in Alaska and Katahdin Woods and Waters Nationwide Monument.
The Economics of Nationwide Monuments
Making a nationwide monument impacts authorities funding. As you possibly can guess, stopping oil, fuel, and even inexperienced vitality growth by establishing a nationwide monument ends in the lack of income to the U.S. authorities. That’s, if these lands had vitality alternatives within the first place.
In 2024, the Biden administration collected $16.4 billion {dollars} in royalties and costs from vitality extraction. That was the best income collected since 1982. The much less talked about and extra sinister challenge is said to hardrock minerals like gold, silver, copper, and lithium. Mining causes large environmental impacts on the panorama, but firms pay no royalties for these extractions.
Alternatively, designating a nationwide monument opens up new alternatives for funding for habitat and conservation. Grants and governmental applications turn into obtainable to lands designation as nationwide monuments. Plus, from an area economic system perspective, us rural people usually profit from a monument designation. A number of analysis research have correlated monument designation with financial alternative.
Within the research “Nationwide Monuments and financial progress within the American West,” researchers discovered “that monuments elevated the typical variety of institutions and jobs in areas close to monuments; elevated the typical institution progress fee; had no impact, optimistic or unfavourable, on the variety of jobs in institutions that existed pre-designation; and had no impact on mining and different industries that use public lands. On web, defending lands as nationwide monuments has been extra assist than hindrance to native economies within the American West.”
Main Historic Wins for Hunters with Nationwide Monuments
Whether or not we notice it or not, hunters have profoundly benefited from Nationwide Monument designations. As a group, we should always rejoice this govt energy. It’s a means for us within the working class to entry huge tracts of unencumbered land. It preserves our really wild locations and experiences.
Alaska
President Carter used the nationwide monument mechanism usually. He grew to become the second-largest protector of public lands as a U.S. president, excluding marine areas. Within the late Nineteen Seventies, the mining and oil industries, together with different personal pursuits, engaged Congress in a serious battle over tens of tens of millions of acres of public land in Alaska. On December 1, 1978, President Carter made the controversial choice to designate 17 nationwide monuments, totaling 56 million acres, successfully ending Congress’s combat. He made one of the controversial land coverage choices of the time—his Teddy Roosevelt-inspired second.
Ultimately, these lands had been faraway from nationwide monument designation when Congress handed the Alaska Nationwide Curiosity Lands Conservation Act (ANILCA) of 1980. The regulation reclassified these lands into nationwide wildlife refuges, preserves, and nationwide parks. Extra not too long ago, the searching group fiercely debated these lands when the federal government thought-about 28 million acres in Alaska for mineral and vitality extraction. President Biden finally protected them in a extremely controversial choice.
Fearmongering articles unfold misinformation by claiming that every one these lands had been closed to searching. Nonetheless, extra fact-based studies highlighted respectable considerations about lowered entry for caribou searching. They be aware that the variety of non-resident tags was insignificant in comparison with the broader points at hand. The Federal Subsistence Board responded by proscribing caribou searching to native subsistence hunters till the caribou inhabitants reached a sustainable stage. Nonetheless, all different types of searching—together with bears, wolves, moose, and small recreation—stay open in these areas.
Bears Ears and Grand Staircase Escalante Nationwide Monuments
Undoubtedly, probably the most dramatic occasions (and wins) for hunters and nationwide monuments revolve round Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante Nationwide Monuments. In 1996, President Invoice Clinton established Grand Staircase-Escalante Nationwide Monument, defending 1.9 million acres. Later, on December 28, 2016, President Barack Obama designated Bears Ears Nationwide Monument at 1.35 million acres by proclamation. Each of those monuments stay open to searching and are protected against closures associated to mineral or vitality growth.
Nonetheless, these two monuments additionally set the stage for the most important challenges to the Antiquities Act. This led to the primary occasion of a president making a web unfavourable affect on public land protections by difficult, not utilizing, the Antiquities Act.
Makes an attempt to Undo the Legacy of the Antiquities Act and the Imaginative and prescient of Theodore Roosevelt
On January 14, 2025, with one foot out of the White Home, President Biden signed two proclamations. He created Chuckwalla Nationwide Monument (624,000 acres) and Sáttítla Highlands Nationwide Monument (224,000 acres). These designations introduced the full quantity of public land protected through the Antiquities Act throughout his presidency to almost 9 million acres. This ranks him among the many high 5 presidents when it comes to creating protected public lands. That whole additionally consists of the restoration of two nationwide monuments—Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante—to their authentic measurement. These two Nationwide Monuments are floor zero for one of the uncommon and controversial interpretations of the Antiquities Act.
Govt Order 13792
The primary web unfavourable use of presidential powers underneath the Antiquities Act to scale back protections for public land occurred on April 26, 2017 by President Donald Trump. Govt Order 13792, titled “Evaluate of Designations Underneath the Antiquities Act,” challenged a number of monument designations. Essentially the most contentious actions had been the discount of Bears Ears Nationwide Monument by 1.1 million acres (an 85 p.c lower) and the reducing of Grand Staircase-Escalante Nationwide Monument by 50 p.c.
Authorized battles ensued, a lot of which had been based mostly on the absence of language addressing the elimination of a nationwide monument. The regulation is rooted within the thought of creation. Attorneys argue that the President lacks the authority to scale back these areas. This interpretation means that the Act grants solely one-way authority, requiring an act of Congress to lower a monument’s measurement or take away its designation.
The Supreme Court docket has upheld the Antiquities Act’s authority each time it has been challenged. Nonetheless, it has by no means dominated on whether or not a president can scale back or revoke a monument. This debate reached the D.C. Appeals Court docket, however the case was dropped after President Biden restored each nationwide monuments to their authentic varieties.
Undertaking 2025
Undertaking 2025 has known as for the whole repeal of the Antiquities Act. In its part on the Division of the Inside, written by Trump’s former BLM Chief, William Perry Pendley.
The chapter states:
“Though President Trump courageously ordered a overview of nationwide monument designations, the results of that overview was inadequate in that solely two nationwide monuments in a single state (Utah) had been adjusted. Monuments in Maine and Oregon, for instance, ought to have been adjusted downward given the discovering of Secretary Ryan Zinke’s overview that they had been improperly designated. The brand new Administration’s overview will allow a recent take a look at previous monument decrees and new ones by President Biden.
Moreover, the brand new Administration should vigorously defend the downward changes it makes to allow a ruling on a President’s authority to scale back the dimensions of nationwide monuments by the U.S. Supreme Court docket. Lastly, the brand new Administration should search repeal of the Antiquities Act of 1906, which permitted emergency motion by a President lengthy earlier than the statutory authority existed for the safety of particular federal lands, comparable to these with wild and scenic rivers, endangered species, or different distinctive locations.”
The Way forward for the Antiquities Act
On March 15, 2025, we realized that the brand new Trump administration intends to reverse the Biden administration’s designations of Chuckwalla and Sáttítla Highlands Nationwide Monuments. Of their assertion, they introduced the choice to “terminate proclamations declaring practically one million acres represent new nationwide monuments that lock up huge quantities of land from financial growth and vitality manufacturing.” This transfer additional cements President Trump’s legacy as a web unfavourable for public land safety.
As soon as once more, the Antiquities Act might discover itself earlier than the nation’s highest courtroom—this time to find out whether or not a sitting president has the authority to dismantle the conservation legacy of previous administrations.
Massive nationwide monuments are public lands open to all, together with hunters, safeguarded from industrial exploitation and personal pursuits. But the way forward for this important presidential instrument for shielding public lands and securing public searching entry stays unsure. Since its inception in 1906, the Antiquities Act has been a landmark victory for working-class Individuals. It ensures that public lands stay in public palms.
Within the spirit of President Theodore Roosevelt—a disruptor within the title of conservation and a champion of public lands—utilizing the Antiquities Act to determine nationwide monuments honors his enduring legacy.
Learn Extra
Recovering America’s Wildlife Act Reintroduced to the 118th Congress
Small-City Searching Economics
Ethics of Bag Limits and Self-Imposed Limits
Public Grouse Documentary – Now Streaming on Varied Platforms
